Trading Analysis
Looking at this SPY 5-minute chart from 9/29/25, analyzing the first two 15-minute candles (9:30-10:00):
Analysis:
The first 30 minutes shows:
- Initial spike - Strong upward momentum at open, pushing above 665.6
- Immediate rejection - Failed to hold highs, sharp selloff begins
- Breakdown - Price crashes through multiple support levels
- Lower highs, lower lows - Classic bearish structure forming
Key observations:
- Red curved lines showing downward momentum
- Price unable to reclaim early highs
- Broken below opening range
- Support levels (horizontal lines) being tested to the downside
- Volume spike on the selloff (visible in the massive red candles)
Verdict: This is a PUT day ๐ป
Trading setup:
- The failed breakout at open is a classic "bull trap"
- Once price broke below the opening range low (~664.5), that confirmed bearish intent
- You'd be looking for puts on bounces/retracements to the downside
- Target those support zones (664.2, 664, 663.8 area)
Risk note: That sharp V-bottom around 9:45 shows some buying interest, so you'd want to be nimble with scalps and watch for any reversal patterns. But the overall structure of the first 30min is definitively bearish - lower highs being printed after the failed open.Full Day Analysis - SPY 9/29/25 ๐
Opening Structure (9:30-10:00)โ
BEARISH - Classic bull trap
- Gap up at open to ~665.60
- Immediate rejection and violent selloff
- Broke opening range low = bearish signal confirmed
- Waterfall decline to 663.89 low (~1.70 point drop in 45 mins)
Why it happened: Likely gap fill from previous day, sellers positioned for the move, weak hands trapped long at the highs.
First Reversal (10:00-10:45)โ
BULLISH ATTEMPT - Failed short squeeze
- Massive V-bottom from 663.89
- Explosive rally back to 665.05 area
- Key Opportunity #1: Calls on the bounce from 663.89-664.00 (high risk/high reward)
- However, failed to reclaim 665.20-665.30 = warning sign
- Created lower high vs opening high (665.60)
Why it failed: Resistance from morning sellers still in control, not enough buying conviction to break through.
Mid-Morning Chop (10:45-12:00)โ
RANGE-BOUND/SLIGHT BEAR
- Consolidation between 664.50-665.05
- Multiple tests of support at 664.50-664.60
- Each bounce getting weaker (lower highs forming)
- Red curved resistance pressing down
- Opportunity #2: Range scalps - buy 664.50, sell 664.90-665.00 (tight stops required)
Lunch Breakdown (12:00-12:30)โ
BEARISH CONTINUATION
- Support at 664.50 finally broke
- This confirmed the bear trend from morning was still intact
- Dropped to new lows around 663.40
- Opportunity #3: Puts on the break of 664.40 targeting 663.50-663.00
Why it happened: Lunch time = low liquidity, stops got run, no buyers stepping in.
Afternoon Recovery Attempts (12:30-2:30)โ
CHOPPY BULLISH - Multiple failed rallies
- Several bounces: 663.40 โ 664.00 โ failed
- Another: 663.00 โ 664.20 โ failed
- Creating a series of higher lows but still under heavy resistance
- Red curved lines acting as dynamic resistance throughout
- Opportunity #4: Quick scalp calls on bounces from 663.00-663.50, but had to take profit fast at 664.00-664.20
Pattern: Bear flag / descending channel - each rally met with selling pressure
Late Day Action (2:30-Close)โ
FINAL PUSH - Small bullish momentum
- Last attempt to reclaim 663.50-664.00 zone
- Some buying came in but still capped
- Closed near 663.70 area (down ~1.40 from HOD)
- Volume dying off = indecision
KEY LEVELS THAT MATTERED:โ
- 665.30-665.60 = Major resistance (morning highs)
- 664.50-664.60 = Critical support that broke midday
- 663.80-664.00 = Battle zone all afternoon
- 663.00-663.40 = Low of day support
OVERALL DAY ASSESSMENT:โ
Primary Bias: PUT DAY ๐ป
Reasons:
- โ Failed breakout at open (bull trap)
- โ Lower highs all day (665.60 โ 665.05 โ 664.80 โ 664.20)
- โ Lower lows (663.89 โ 663.40 โ 663.00)
- โ Every rally attempt failed at resistance
- โ Red curved moving averages providing constant downward pressure
- โ Closed near lows of day
Best Opportunities:
- #1 BEST: Puts after break of opening range low (~9:45 AM) - that confirmed the trend
- #2: Puts on failed rally at 665.00 (10:15-10:30) - lower high rejection
- #3: Puts on breakdown of 664.50 support (~12:15 PM) - clear break of key level
- Scalp plays: Quick calls on oversold bounces at 663.00-663.50, but required discipline to take profit
What NOT to do:
- โ Hold calls hoping for reversal - every bounce failed
- โ Short the absolute lows (663.00) - risky, better to short rallies
- โ Fight the trend - red curved lines were your guide all day
Pattern Recognition: This was a classic trending day down with weak counter-trend bounces. The tell was the first 30 minutes - when that opening range broke to the downside with conviction, the script was written. LESSONS LEARNED FROM 9/29/25 SPY TRADING DAY ๐
๐ฏ CRITICAL LESSONSโ
1. The First 30 Minutes Sets The Toneโ
LESSON: When the opening range breaks with conviction (especially on high volume), that's often your directional bias for the session.
- The break below opening range at 9:45 AM was THE signal
- Don't fight it, trade with it
- Rule: Wait for opening range to establish (9:30-10:00), then trade the break
2. Failed Breakouts Are High-Probability Setupsโ
LESSON: That gap-up to 665.60 followed by immediate rejection = bull trap
- When price makes a new high and can't hold it = reversal signal
- The "trap" creates a pool of trapped longs who become sellers
- Rule: Look for quick rejections at key levels - they often lead to strong moves in opposite direction
3. Lower Highs + Lower Lows = Stay Bearishโ
LESSON: The trend was crystal clear all day:
- 665.60 โ 665.05 โ 664.80 โ 664.20 (lower highs)
- 663.89 โ 663.40 โ 663.00 (lower lows)
- Rule: Don't fight established trend structure. Trade WITH the trend, not against it
4. Counter-Trend Bounces Require Quick Profitsโ
LESSON: Those big green candles looked tempting, but EVERY rally failed
- The 663.89 โ 665.05 bounce? Faded
- The 663.40 โ 664.00 bounce? Faded
- The 663.00 โ 664.20 bounce? Faded
- Rule: In a strong trend, counter-trend trades = scalps only. Take profit FAST (30-50 cents, not hoping for full reversal)
โ ๏ธ TRAPS & GOTCHASโ
TRAP #1: The Morning Bull Trap ๐ชคโ
- What happened: Open at 665.60 looked bullish, but was a trap
- The gotcha: FOMO buying the high, then getting crushed
- How to avoid: Wait 15-30 mins before trading. Let the real trend reveal itself
- Better play: Sold puts when it broke 665.20 support
TRAP #2: "It's Oversold, Time to Buy!" ๐ชคโ
- What happened: Multiple times hit oversold (663.89, 663.40, 663.00)
- The gotcha: Each bounce looked like "the bottom" but wasn't
- How to avoid: Oversold can stay oversold in trending markets
- Better play: Short the bounces, don't try to catch falling knives
TRAP #3: The 10:00-10:30 Fake Reversal ๐ชคโ
- What happened: Huge green candles from 663.89 โ 665.05
- The gotcha: "Bears are done! It's a V-bottom recovery!"
- How to avoid: Check if it reclaims ABOVE key resistance (665.30). It didn't = still bearish
- Better play: Sell calls into that strength at 664.90-665.05
TRAP #4: Holding Through Lunch ๐ชคโ
- What happened: 664.50 support looked solid for 1.5 hours, then broke at lunch
- The gotcha: Low liquidity lunch = stops get run, violent moves
- How to avoid: Tighten stops or close positions before 12:00-1:00 PM
- Better play: Exit before lunch or trade the lunch breakdown fresh
TRAP #5: "Every Dip Is A Buy" ๐ชคโ
- What happened: Multiple dips (664.50, 664.00, 663.50) that continued lower
- The gotcha: Averaging down on calls in a downtrend = death by 1000 cuts
- How to avoid: In downtrends, every dip leads to lower dips
- Better play: Buy dips only when trend changes (higher highs formed)
โ DO'sโ
-
DO wait for confirmation
- Opening range break = confirmation
- Don't assume direction pre-market
-
DO respect key levels
- 665.30, 664.50, 663.89 were critical
- Price action at these levels tells the story
-
DO use the moving averages
- Those red curved lines were resistance all day
- When price under MAs + MAs pointing down = stay bearish
-
DO take profits on counter-trend trades
- That 663.89 โ 665.05 bounce? 1+ points!
- Should've taken profit at 664.80-665.00, not hoped for full reversal
-
DO trade the pattern
- Lower highs + lower lows = short rallies
- Don't overcomplicate it
-
DO scale in/out
- Don't go all-in on one entry
- Build positions as confirmation comes
-
DO use proper stops
- Puts: stop if it reclaims 665.30+ strongly
- Calls: stop if breaks below key support levels
โ DON'Tsโ
-
DON'T fight the trend
- Biggest mistake = buying calls after 10:00 AM hoping for reversal
- The trend was down, period
-
DON'T hold losers hoping
- If your call is down 30-50% and trend hasn't changed, cut it
- Hope is not a strategy
-
DON'T ignore volume
- Big volume on the opening dump = conviction
- Low volume on bounces = weak, likely to fail
-
DON'T revenge trade
- Missed the morning breakdown? Don't chase
- Wait for next setup (failed rally to short)
-
DON'T overtrade the chop
- That 10:45-12:00 range was tight
- Sometimes sitting out is the best trade
-
DON'T buy the "V-bottom"
- Just because it bounced hard doesn't mean trend changed
- Need higher highs confirmed, not just bounce
-
DON'T ignore resistance
- Every rally hit 664.80-665.05 and failed
- That's telling you something - listen!
-
DON'T hold through major time frames
- Lunch (12-1 PM) and Power Hour (3-4 PM) can reverse positions
- Take profit or tighten stops before these times
๐ STRATEGIC LESSONSโ
Position Sizingโ
- Early morning (9:30-10:30): Smaller size, volatility is WILD
- Confirmed trend (10:30-12:00): Can size up on high-probability setups
- Lunch (12:00-1:00): Reduce size or sit out
- Afternoon (1:00-3:30): Moderate size, watch for reversal patterns
Risk Managementโ
- Max loss per trade: 20-30% of position
- If wrong 2-3 times in a row: Step away, reassess
- Daily loss limit: Hit it? Done for the day. Live to trade tomorrow
Entry Timingโ
- Best entries today:
- Short at 665.00-665.20 (failed opening range)
- Short at 665.00-665.05 (failed V-bottom recovery)
- Short at 664.50 break (lunch breakdown)
- Quick calls at 663.00-663.40 (oversold bounces) with TIGHT profit targets
Exit Timingโ
- In trend: Trail stops, let winners run (but not through lunch!)
- Counter-trend: FAST profits (30-50 cents for scalps)
- If thesis breaks: Exit immediately (if shorting and breaks above 665.30)